3 comforting spots for comfort food

By:  | November 25, 2024 |  Dining |  Monmouth County

By Ryan Loughlin

With the temperatures falling and that pile of big bulky sweaters starting to make regular appearances in your weekly wardrobe, now is the time of year where those cravings for comfort foods seem to creep in. Those with willpower may ignore them, but for the rest of us, diving headfirst into these stick-to-your-ribs indulgences is an unofficial tradition of the winter season. Here are three great spots to indulge:

Mulligan’s Restaurant & Grill (Farmingdale) - A great, no-frills spot to catch a game or throw down a few beers, Mulligan’s is a roadside treasure. New ownership just took over in October, but a recent trip has confirmed that quality has remained top notch and the prices noticeably affordable. The menu is classic pub grub, so the standouts as far as comfort foods are concerned are plentiful. The grilled cheeses are superb, and an entire sub section of the menu is devoted to them, with our favorite being the Jersey Grilled Cheese, a high-piled stack of pork roll and American cheese on a pair of perfectly griddled rye bread slices. The wings are excellent as well (go for the Hot ‘n’ Honey variety) and came out super crispy. And of course one can’t overlook their fabulous Rat Rock Chili, an award-winning cup of beefy goodness that you could easily make a meal out of all on its own. OriginalMulligans.com

Dublin House (Red Bank) – Dublin House is a Red Bank legend and serves as a favorite spot to hit before catching a show at the Count Basie or The Vogel. The fun Irish Pub design is homey and comforting all on its own, and one could easily spend an entire night here just enjoying pints of Guinness. But doing that would be a mistake, as you would miss out on their fabulous Shepherd’s Pie, an emerald isle staple that is a must-do any time you walk through these doors. Ground lamb, and savory vegetables get topped with a blanket of mashed potatoes and a crown of cheddar cheese that gets baked to perfection and served with a spoon. Those looking to expand into even more comforting territory can order the Irish Surf and Turf — a sampler consisting of Shepherd’s Pie, Fish and Chips and Bangers and Mash all on the same plate. The DublinHouse.co

Mutiny BBQ Co. (Asbury Park) – Great barbecue can be tricky to find in New Jersey, but there are a handful of spots that do it justice, and Mutiny BBQ Co. in Asbury Park is definitely one of them. The menu is loaded up with classic smokehouse faves including pulled pork, racks of ribs, brisket and more. Perhaps the most indulgent comfort food option of all is “The Beast From the East,” a towering and downright intimidating sandwich that boasts a quarter pound each of pulled pork and brisket as well as coleslaw, pickles, pickled red onions and a full Texas sausage link resting on a vastly overmatched Martin’s potato roll. Oh, and it can be topped with pimento cheese as well, and why not, because at this point you’ve clearly stopped worrying about your health altogether. While you’re at it, you might as well grab a few sides too, and you can’t go wrong with their ultra-hearty brisket chili – a bean-free delight that you almost certainly will not be able to finish; or their cornbread casserole, which takes the deliciousness of cornbread and transforms it into the consistency of Stove Top stuffing. MutinyBBQ.com